The Critique
On a recent episode of “First Take,” Smith delivered a pointed message to Harden about why the criticism follows him and it has nothing to do with a lack of championships.
“Everybody brings up his performance in terms of how anemic he has played in big-game situations. James Harden, I hope you’re watching, you’re one of the greatest scorers in the history of basketball.”
“It’s not because you ain’t great, it’s because we’ve seen you be great.”
The Numbers Don’t Lie
For a player who built his reputation on offensive brilliance, those numbers are damning. But Smith argues the stats miss the point. The real issue is the passivity.
“You didn’t even attempt to make noise,” Smith said. “When you don’t attempt the shots, that’s tantamount to quitting in our eyes. We know he can get a shot off anytime he wants to.”
The New Opportunity
Now with the Cleveland Cavaliers, Harden has a chance to rewrite the narrative. He’s no longer required to carry the entire scoring load. Donovan Mitchell who averages 30.5 points in his career Game 7 appearances handles that.
This setup is different. For the first time since leaving Houston, Harden isn’t the sole engine. He’s a critical component, but not the only one.
What’s at Stake
If Harden can guide the Cavaliers deep into the 2026 playoffs and hold his own in any potential Game 7 scenario the conversations about his legacy could shift dramatically.
Not because his numbers will suddenly explode. But because his willingness to control the game, whether through scoring or playmaking, will finally match the moment.
The Bottom Line
Stephen A. Smith’s message to Harden wasn’t criticism for criticism’s sake. It was a challenge from someone who recognizes greatness and refuses to watch it shrink when the lights are brightest.
“It’s not because you ain’t great.”Harden knows he’s great. The question is whether, when it matters most, he’ll finally prove it.
